"Why not at me?" Reasons Jack, threading their fingers together. "This is a thing. We're a thing. He matters to you. You matter to me." He shrugs. "It's okay, Poison."
Other options:
no subject
"Why not at me?" Reasons Jack, threading their fingers together. "This is a thing. We're a thing. He matters to you. You matter to me." He shrugs. "It's okay, Poison."